Is lying okay sometimes
And if telling a particular lie produces a worse result than not telling it, telling it would be a bad thing to do. This will help to stop deception with positive intent. In another study, we also found that participants were actually less satisfied with the prize they received when it resulted from a paternalistic lie.
But sometimes the situation calls for a compliment or two, at which point it's acceptable to tell a white lie. Tell him it was the best pasta ever, or that you loved her new take on the traditional American meal.
Is it ok to lie to protect someone
In this case, falsely telling someone that they did a great job could be considered a paternalistic lie—that is, a lie that requires the deceiver to make assumptions about whether lying is in the best interest of the person being deceived. A young child is rescued from a plane crash in a very weakened state. When Asked For Your Personal Info If your coworker is prying into your personal life, or someone at the bar is demanding your phone number , then it may be time to save yourself with a white lie. If an act of deception were uncovered in public, it could result in a severe blow to your reputation. Others include 'living a lie'; those cases where someone behaves in a way that misleads the rest of us as to their true nature. When Running Late To Work If you have a super strict job, then you know the awfulness that is running late to work. And that's perfectly OK. For example, you can ask your significant other whether they really want to know how they look when they ask you; and a doctor can ask their patients how much they want to know about their prognosis, or whether they would like to focus conversations on their treatment options. Say you're sorry, tell them they're right — do whatever you gotta do to put an end to the whole thing.
So where do we draw the line? The patients were under light anesthesia. Why We Tell White Lies As a parent, using white lies to help prevent a child from feeling upset is a common practice, and according to researchis socially acceptable across many cultures.
Three specific inferences underlie this judgment. But if you want to know when it's acceptable to drop a lie, read on for 11 times it might just be OK.
This is an example of 'rule-utilitarianism'; considering every single action separately is 'act-Utilitarianism'. People understand.
Is lying okay sometimes
First inspect our own conscience and ask whether the lie is justified Second, ask friends or colleagues, or people with special ethical knowledge what they think about the particular case Thirdly, consult some independent persons about it This sort of test is most useful when considering what we might call 'public' lying - when an institution is considering just how much truth to tell about a project - perhaps a medical experiment, or a proposed war, or an environmental development. When asked whether he had discussed any matters other than Cuban missiles with the Soviets he absolutely denied it. In these situations, a little lie is polite, right, and just what the person needs to hear. If every lie told could prevent harm to another person, without any ill-effects, it would make the answer to this question more clear. When Receiving An Odd Gift Is your grandma known for re-gifting old cookware with ancient crumbs included? If an act of deception were uncovered in public, it could result in a severe blow to your reputation. But hey, that's part of being in a relationship. Last year, Gerald Dworkin wrote about this in the New York Times and listed 10 lying scenarios he approved of. This is a major development in ethical research, because until now, lies have been studied as a single category of selfish, wrongheaded behavior. When You Want To Cancel Plans There's often no way to cancel plans without sounding like a horrible person — especially when it's because you'd rather sit at home alone.
Even as we transition into adulthood, well-meaning lies are often told to shield a person from criticism or added hardship. But what could we do in the real world?
When is it ok to lie bible
Do you know whether the person with whom you are talking prefers comfort over candor in this context? If honesty is a virtue in the particular system involved, then lying is a bad thing. Why is lying wrong? Where do you draw your line? To determine whether your lies will be seen as paternalistic, ask yourself the following questions: Can you safely assume that most people would be better off with the outcome associated with lying, rather than the truth? What would a public jury of reasonable persons say about this lie? For example, you can ask your significant other whether they really want to know how they look when they ask you; and a doctor can ask their patients how much they want to know about their prognosis, or whether they would like to focus conversations on their treatment options. If they ask for your opinion, it's OK to tell them they look great — even if you highly disagree. His parents have been killed in the crash but he is unaware of this.
based on 112 review