Writing an argument primary resources history
Evaluating primary sources
Although the picture does not show horses and oxen, other sources of muscle power, it implies their presence. Analysis or interpretation of data. Historians are still scouring old newspapers to find these texts and building archives online to share them. To evaluate secondary sources, explore the following parts of the text or artifact by following these steps: 1. Keep the following in mind when reading primary sources. The name suggests a place — a region whose borders are as inexact and shifting as a sand dune. Both fiction and non-fiction writers use story-telling devices not only to engage readers and communicate their values explicitly, but also to guide the reader through a complicated argument. Signposts: Guide your readers through an argument Narrative devices that help guide your readers are the signposts pointing the way through a complex argument. Should Fiege take a stronger stance when interpreting the central image of the cotton picker? Cite specific examples. Educators should review primary sources carefully and be prepared for any slurs and other hateful or hurtful speech. How "neutral" is the text; how much does the author have a stake in you reading it, i.
Explain what you think this position may be and why you think it. What is the story line? A primary source essay should not be a restatement or summary of the document's content. You can use this as your outline for your notes or create your own brief outline.
Presuppositions How do the ideas and values in the source differ from the ideas and values of our age? Help Primary Sources Primary Sources are immediate, first-hand accounts of a topic, from people who had a direct connection with it.
What ongoing historiographical discussion e.
2. when would you use primary sources when writing an essay
Ideally, however, conclusions are made only after carefully considering multiple explanations. In the "Inscription of Tiglathpileser I" the Assyrian ruler describes himself as Readers will know that a key point or evidence is related to an earlier discussion much more readily if you signpost through the discussion. Give some thought to your thesis before taking notes and outlining, lest you end up with pages and pages of pointless evidence. Speeches, diaries, letters and interviews - what the people involved said or wrote. What role might the translator have played in shaping the document's tone or content? A primary source such as a journal entry or the online version, a blog , at best, may only reflect one individual's opinion on events, which may or may not be truthful, accurate, or complete. Think about the following questions as you critically examine the source s : Authorship: What do you know about the author's background? Pollan starts off with a familiar question that most of us ask on a regular basis, and then moves on to make the claim that modern food supply systems have led recent generations to lose the connection to their food. Literary techniques such as foreshadowing are also effective signposts. Trove has primary sources from Australia. Think carefully about which of the broader narratives of environmental history your argument will become a part of.
based on 26 review